Today's Learning: Kelim 9:1-2 O.C. 590:1-3 Nidah 72 Hamaayan / The Torah Spring Edited by Shlomo Katz Nitzavim-Vayelech Vol. XI, No. 50 (533) 25 Elul 5757, September 27, 1997 On the opening verse of our parashah, "You all are standing here today," the midrash comments: Just as the day is part light and part dark, so you, too, will have dark, but in the future, it will become light for you. When? When you are joined as one group." Rav Nachum Mordechai Friedman (the "Chortkover Rebbe") z"l writes: Chazal mean to teach us that just as when the day becomes dark, it is because the earth has turned away from the source of light (the sun), so, too, when it becomes dark for us, it is because we have turned away from the Source of light. It is not because the "light" has gone away, but because our sins have built a wall between us and the "light." This midrash also teaches: Just as you know with certainty that the sun will rise in the morning, so you must believe with unshakable faith indeed, you must know that "light" will be restored to you. Finally, do not think that just as you can calculate the time of sunrise, so you can calculate the time of G-d's salvation (i.e., the return of the "light"). When will it happen? Only when you are joined as one group! (Doresh Tov) ****************** "You are all standing today, before Hashem, your G-d; the heads of your tribes, your elders, and your officers all the men of Israel; your small children, your wives, and your proselyte who is in the midst of your camp, from the hewer of your wood to the drawer of your water, for you to pass into the covenant of Hashem . . ." (29:9-11) Philosophers divided people into several categories. The unlearned masses who observed the Torah's laws, they said, were like those who try to reach the king's palace, but never see it. Those who study Talmud only are like those who circle the palace, but never enter it. Those who study philosophy enter the palace, and the most expert among these actually reach the throne room. Our verses prove that this is not so, writes Rav Moshe Avigdor Amiel z"l (Chief Rabbi of Antwerp and Tel Aviv). Even the water carrier and the woodcutter can pass into the covenant of Hashem. (L'nevochei Hatekufah Ch. 13) ****************** Parashat Nitzavim in Halachah * None of the Torah's 613 mitzvot appear in the parashah. * "It [the Torah] is not in the heavens." (30:12) From this verse, Chazal learn that once the Torah was "sealed" at the end of Moshe's life, no prophet may change it. G-d has given the Torah to us to interpret according to the rules that the Torah itself contains, and even if He would tell us how to act, we would listen only to the Torah, as interpreted by the sages. (See, for example, Bav Metzia 59b and Temurah 16a) And yet, we find instances where sages consulted angels regarding the proper psak halachah/halachic decision. Rav Yaakov of Marvege, a 12th century Tosafist, did so regularly, and composed the work She'eilot Uteshuvot Min Hashamayim ("Responsa from Heaven"). Indeed, this work is quoted by poskim and followed! Rav Chaim Yosef David Azulai z"l ("Chida") explains that the Heavens may be consulted when the gemara has discussed a question and left it unanswered. In such a case, there is no way that we can be expected to resolve the matter using our own intellectual abilities. (Shem Hagedolim, Ma'arechet Gedolim, erech Rav Yaakov Hechassid) ****************** Parashat Vayelech in Halachah * The last two of the Torah's 613 mitzvot appear in this parashah. One of them is the mitzvah of hakhel. This mitzvah is for all men, women and children to gather in Yerushalayim once every seven years to hear the king read from the Torah. (Sefer Hachinuch) * The last of the Torah's 613 mitzvot is the mitzvah to write a sefer Torah. (Sefer Hachinuch) * The halachah states that every column of a Sefer Torah must have a minimum number of lines, but the last column may be smaller. Thus, writes Rav Meir Shapiro z"l (see page 4), we see that an incomplete page at the end of a work is called a page. With this principle, Rav Shapiro answered the following question from a Daf Yomi student writing from Berlin: Since the last daf of a tractate usually does not fill the entire page, does one fulfill his obligation to learn Daf Yomi by learning that page? (This question presumes that undertaking to learn Daf Yomi has the force of a vow.) Rav Shapiro writes that it does have the force of a vow, for the gemara itself teaches, "If one says, 'I will arise early and learn such-and-such, he has vowed a great vow to the G-d of Yisrael'." However, the "incomplete" last page also qualifies as a page. Also, as with any vow, the halachah interprets the vow with reference to the circumstances of its making. Since it was announced at the outset that the first siyum/completion would take place on Tu B'shvat 1931, one can calculate that these partial pages do count. (She'eilot Uteshuvot Ohr Hameir No. 75) ****************** THE DAF HAYOMI As many readers are aware, tomorrow (Sunday) is the last day of the tenth cycle of "Daf Hayomi" study. The following essay pays tribute to this historic event. Superficially, one could describe the Daf Hayomi (commonly called "Daf Yomi") as an undertaking in which participants worldwide study the same page of Talmud Bavli (gemara) on any given day and complete it every 2702 days. Rav Meir Shapiro z"l, the tzaddik who first promoted the concept, saw it much differently: " The Daf Yomi is a bridge [he said], though fashioned of paper which lifts the Jew above the stormy confusion of the waters below, and he walks with more assurance and confidence than on the firmest steel structure. " The great allure of the Daf Yomi concept lies in the realization that the daf (page) of gemara which I learn here and now is being poured over by countless Jews scattered over the face of the earth. While each one has his own particular mode of learning and is influenced by the intellectual climate of his environment, nevertheless, Abaye and Rava [two great sages of the Talmud] remain Abaye and Rava." (From Rav Meir Shapiro's remarks on the occasion of the first completion of the Daf Yomi cycle on Tu B'shvat 5691/1931, reprinted in the Jewish Observer, Vol. XXII No. 1) The two-fold purpose of Daf Yomi, first begun on Rosh Hashanah 5684/1924, was to encourage Jews to increase their Torah study through the implementation of a regimented program or quota, and to provide a vehicle for uniting Jews worldwide. Rav Meir Shapiro himself observed on the occasion mentioned above: " It was on my first trip abroad on behalf of the yeshiva of Lublin [in 1927, to the U.S., England, and Western Europe], when I found groups and individuals learning the daf in every Jewish community I visited, that I saw at first hand the impact that Daf Yomi has made in the Jewish world. Whether it was in Strasbourg, London or Baltimore [here he mentioned by name people whom he had met], while their styles of learning differed, there was the same motivating force which is inherent in Daf Yomi." In every generation since the Daf Yomi was introduced, many gedolim (leading sages) have endorsed it. The Gerrer Rebbe studied the daf and encouraged his chassidim to do so. The Chafetz Chaim reportedly told Rav Meir Shapiro, "In Heaven, they love you dearly." Rav Aharon Kotler z"l, the leading sage in America in the 1950's, studied Daf Yomi as well. The success of the Daf Yomi is evident from the number of works whose authors credit their own relatives with giving the idea to Rav Meir Shapiro. (One such claim notes that Rav Meir Shapiro was a devout Chortkover chassid, and states that the Chortkover Rebbe, Rav Yisrael Friedman z"l, suggested that idea to Rav Shapiro and asked that Rav Shapiro announce it in his own name.) In addition to the advantages of Daf Yomi which Rav Meir Shapiro himself described, Rav Moshe Feinstein z"l notes that it gives the person the opportunity to complete the entire Torah. Rav Feinstein proves from various sources that every person is obligated to do this during his lifetime (Igrot Moshe, Yorah Deah II No. 110). Rav Feinstein notes that centuries ago it was common practice to study a page of Talmud each day, and many towns had a chevrah shas (Talmud society) which did just that (Igrot Moshe, Y.D. IV No. 36). Rav Yaakov of Lissa z"l (the "Nesivos") wrote in his famous ethical will almost 200 years ago that his sons should study a page of gemara every day. ****************** From the Humor of Our Sages . . . "I am 120 years old today." (31:2) In his later years, Rav Meir Simcha of Dvinsk z"l (author of Meshech Chochmah) was asked his age. "A businessman who is running short of cash doesn't reveal his cash flow to others."